Knitting (Nope) the Complicated Oxbow Cardigan

Knitting the Oxbow cardigan sweater

I had informally decided to give sweater knitting a break, along with shawl knitting. Then I changed my mind when I saw the Oxbow Cardigan pattern.

The pattern is by Andrea Mowry of Drea Renee Knits and I have never knit any of her patterns although she is everywhere and is very popular with knitters. She seems to have patterns that are above my skill level (this one has only reinforced my belief), but it looked simple enough, with big yarn and big needles. Heck, she made them for the whole family!

Ha! Fooled again…..I have not found this project to be easy at all AND spoiler alert – I frogged it (ripped it out to save the yarn) on April 28th. I feel very good about that too.

How It All Began – My History With This Project

The yarn is bulky so I figured knitting the sweater would be quick. In fact I finished ONE Oxbow sleeve in two days, but man did I struggle, and it didn’t look all that great. But I learned from my efforts and the second sleeve went better.

The Yarn

Brooklyn Tweed Quarry yarn in color Geode
Brooklyn Tweed yarn in color “Geode”

I am using Brooklyn Tweed Quarry in “Geode”, which is a gray-lavender color. My first impression with Quarry yarn was a year or so ago when I bought dark colors to knit warm hats for my kids. As I tried to cast-on, the yarn suddenly came apart! I was very unhappy. I’ve since used this same yarn to knit a hat and have had better luck. I think I just came across a weak section of yarn and didn’t know how to deal with it. It cannot be pulled tightly, so you do have to take care and twist the strand if necessary.

Quarry yarn is bulky, yet very light weight – surprisingly so. Because of this it dries quickly when hand washed (don’t put it in the washer or dryer) and will not weigh you down as a garment. I bought mine at Wool & Company, and they wound all 7 skeins for free! (US shipping is free too, for any order!)

I was interested in this yarn because it is spun in Harrisville, New Hampshire, near where I used to live! The wool comes from Wyoming ?, is spun in NH, and then dyed in another part of the US, so it is totally American made.

trying on the Oxbow sweater sleeve as I knit
Oxbow sleeve knitting in progress

Knitting the Oxbow Sleeves

This is only my third sweater knitting project, (see Fine Sand and Umpqua) if you don’t count the little Popover for a child (I didn’t like that one either). So I am nowhere near being a sweater-knitting expert.

My first mistake was at the beginning, when I used the larger needles to cast on and knit the ribbing. I was supposed to use the smaller size.

Because my gauge swatch was telling me to go up a needle size, and I couldn’t find (and didn’t really want) larger needles, I decided to knit the sweater one size larger. Is that a good idea? I don’t know.

So I began my sleeve. Once the increases happened I got confused. Other knitters had questions too. I know because I saw them on Ravelry. As I knit along trying to figure out what to do with the pattern as the increases were made, I finally figured it out, but not before I made the underside of the sleeve look icky.

knitting the sleeve notes on Oxbow sweater
Making increases on the sleeves

Figuring Out The Sleeve Increases

This information may help you, if you decide to try this pattern. The problem arises when you come to the increase rows.

I added markers to show where the increase area was. The orange marker shows the BOR. Each time I would work a round I would count backwards – in pattern – from the original beginning (where I also placed a marker) to start the pattern from the BOR. Nothing in the directions advises this! You have to wing it.

I didn’t figure this out for a while, so my underarm of the sleeve is a bit messed up. This part will be towards my body and not easily seen. (The pattern simply says to make increases and knit in pattern. Ya, the directions are not impressive.) I did do better on sleeve #2.

finished sleeve
Mistakes are apparent on the underside of my first sleeve

Sleeves Get Long!

My sleeve also began to get really long before I was done with making my increases! So I decided to go back and follow the next smaller size directions. If I had tried to get all the increases made my sleeves would have been way too long! (I saw comments on this same problem from other knitters). As it is, the sleeve is still a little longer, which is always better than too short!

Finished sleeve knitting for Oxbox
One sleeve finished

The Oxbow repeat pattern is nice and makes a fluffy texture, but it’s not all that easy to follow. It’s an easy enough pattern with 2 row repeats, it’s just not easy to keep track of the rows. What I did was use the orange clip marker to give me reference for inches (length) and then I could pay attention to the pattern better.

On To the Body and Decreases

Now I have knit the body of the Oxbow sweater to the decrease section. Wow, all I can say is really read through all the info before you begin. Basically it comes down to knitting in the pattern, but adding decreases at each end of the row (every so many rows, depending on size).

I am knitting the size “Women 42” for a good bit of ease. Once I got to the body and neck and yoke decreases, I faltered. I set the sweater aside until I could concentrate and really figure out what to do. THIS IS NOT AN EASY KNIT! Also not something to set aside for long in fear I will forget what I was doing and have to re-read it all again!

The directions are not easy to understand and I can only hope I will finish this and have it be wearable. The designer talks like this is the simplest sweater ever to make ….. and gee, why not whip one up for every family member? NOT! If I get through this one, I doubt I will ever make another. I’m just being honest here, whereas I have my doubts about some reviews I’ve read.

Knitting the Oxbow cardigan sweater
Knitting progress on the Oxbow

For now, this sweater is on hold. I’m partway done with the body and have two sleeves completed. I do plan to finish it, but currently I’m on a mitten-knitting kick. So I’m publishing this post and will update it when I finally finish this hellish sweater knitting project.

Oxbow Frogging Complete!

Every time I would pass by the knitting bag holding the Oxbow sweater, I would feel pressure to get working on it. But I didn’t want to. When I did get it out, I had difficulty finding where the heck I was in the pattern. I was at a decrease every 5 rows, while doing the 4 row repeat with knits and purls done at such and such and P2tog or SSK done at here and here…. Just reading it was mind boggling. Sorry, but I think it was a very lazy way to write a pattern.

I contemplated all my work – 2 sleeves done and about halfway up the body. But tearing it out made me feel calmer than pressing onward. So I frogged it. Now I have tons of Quarry yarn and must find another sweater to knit. (Eventually I knit one by Espace Tricot). But today I feel good, and will no longer see this sweater sitting around driving me crazy!

How Do You Know When to Just Give Up?

My first instinct is to rip the whole thing out. I’m talking knitting here, and looking at a big mistake, or a very tough and time-consuming mistake to fix. Are you calm, cool and collected and simply get on with the fix? Or, like me do you see lots of unraveling ahead – like the…

Rate this:

Read More…

18 thoughts on “Knitting (Nope) the Complicated Oxbow Cardigan

  1. Pingback: Knitting Cobblestone Cardigan #2 in Blue – New England's Narrow Road

  2. Pingback: How Do You Know When to Just Give Up? – New England's Narrow Road

  3. Pingback: Brooklyn Tweed’s Woolen Spun “Shelter” and “Quarry” – New England's Narrow Road

  4. Pingback: Knit the Warm-Up Sweater – A Free Pattern – New England's Narrow Road

  5. Pingback: Knitting Setbacks and Frustrations – New England's Narrow Road

  6. Anonymous

    I am so glad to hear I am not the only one who is struggling to knit this sweater…. I have not let myself knit anything else until I finish this sweater. The result is I am ignoring my knitting and feel torn as to what I should do… I am so close to being done, but the decreases are killing me!


    1. Pam

      I know the feeling. I got past the problem with the sleeves, but for the body, it got to the point where it was not fun, in fact I dreaded seeing the project sitting in it’s bin….so I had to stop. I wish you luck if you persevere because I think the overall look is just wonderful….


  7. Anonymous

    So happy to find out I’m not alone , I tried so hard to finish this pattern ,totally agree about lousy instructions and alas finally I ripped it out and now searching for a project to use all my Quarry yarn. Have knitted a shawl by Drea Renee Knits and it came out really nice.
    Thank you and happy knitting.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Anonymous

    I so wanted to knit this sweater for a dear friend who was undergoing chemo, alas NO! Oh how I tried to understand the decreases (ripping back and reknitting 3X) but no way could I understand (and I consider myself a moderately experienced knitter). A big thumbs down on this pattern!


    1. Pam

      I agree, as you know. Knitting should be fun, and for the most part relaxing… not this one! Sorry you had such trouble. In fact this pattern has turned me off for trying to knit any type of sweater with an all over texture.


  9. Pingback: Knitting Review of The Oulu Mitts Colorwork Pattern – New England's Narrow Road

  10. Pingback: Photos of My Turtle Dove Sweater / Poncho – New England's Narrow Road

  11. Pingback: Understanding the Turtle Dove Sweater Pattern Increases – New England's Narrow Road

  12. Pingback: Patterns and Yarn, Hits and Misses So Far in 2020 – New England's Narrow Road

  13. maire

    i know i will never pay that much again for a pattern that is so confusing! her patterns are gorgeous but she spends no time in detailing what to do. especially as the stitches are what count. i am so glad i am not the only one to feel this way I wish i had your advice before i wasted 12 $$ this was so helpful

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Pam

      I knew I couldn’t be the only one who felt this way about this pattern! It may be that you must be very experienced, with sweaters anyway, to knit this, but why not just say so? It has kind of turned me off of her patterns. I still have all this yarn, so one day maybe a Tin Can Knits sweater. I’m glad to hear this info helped you, even though it was too late. It’s really why I am writing this blog, to share my honest experience with knitting fun and flops.


  14. Pingback: Knitters and Covid, A Good Time to Stash Dive – New England's Narrow Road

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.